We acted for the successful plaintiff in a copyright infringement action in the Federal Court involving curated lists of third-party hyperlinks. The Court confirmed that copyright may subsist in a compilation of third party links created through the selection, sequencing and organization of the links. You can read about the case in our blog post.
About Howard Winkler
Howard is a senior advisor to Shift Law in litigation related matters. He is also the founder and principal of Winkler Dispute Resolution.
With over 30 years of experience, Howard has developed a well-deserved reputation in the Ontario legal community for his advocacy skills and his practical approach to conflict resolution. Howard regularly represents both plaintiffs and defendants in complex factual and legal disputes both at trial and at all levels of Appeal, particularly in media law and reputational related matters. He has been a Certified Specialist in Civil Litigation for most of his career and he has been described by the CBC as one of the country’s leading experts in Defamation Law.
In addition to being an experienced litigator, Howard is a sought after mediator. Drawing on his many years of litigation experience, Howard has a keen sense of how cases will be viewed by courts which can help to set realistic expectations and assess various settlement scenarios.
Throughout his legal career, Howard’s views on various topics and some of his higher profile cases have been profiled in trade journals and in the popular press.
Howard is Harvard Law School trained in dispute resolution and negotiation.
SPECIAL DESIGNATIONS
Certified by the Law Society of Upper Canada as a Specialist in Civil Litigation.
Appointed as a Fellow of the Litigation Counsel of America, Trial Lawyer Honorary Society.
Named to the Martindale-Hubbell Bar Register of Preeminent Lawyers for earning the highest level of professional skill and integrity in the Martindale-Hubbell Law Directory.
Peer rated as a Best Lawyer in Canada in the area of Defamation and Media Law in every year since the inception of the Best Lawyers program in Canada.
Contributing Author, Bullen & Leake Canadian Precedents of Pleadings (Carswell).
Client Work
Insights

The latest from the Federal Court on “new evidence” in Trademarks Opposition Board appeals
It has been more than a year since an amendment to the Trademarks Act came into force requiring parties to appeals from the Trademarks Opposition Board (the “TMOB”) to obtain leave to file new evidence. The requirement, under section 56(5), has generated a growing body of case law that began with Products Unlimited, Inc v…

John Simpson recognized in the 2027 edition of The Best Lawyers in Canada™
Shift Law is pleased to announce that John Simpson has once again been recognized in The Best Lawyers in Canada™ for his exceptional work in Intellectual Property Law. This marks the sixth consecutive year that John has received this honour, having been recognized by Best Lawyers in this practice area since 2022. Best Lawyers recognition…

Federal Court confirms copyright can subsist in a curated list of third-party links
Can a list of hyperlinks to someone else’s content enjoy copyright protection? According to the Federal Court, it can. In Rayman v. Red Crayon Inc., 2026 FC 951, the Court held that copyright may subsist in the original selection and listing of hyperlinks to third-party materials and that significant damages can be awarded for unauthorized…
Contact us
Let us know what you need help with. We’ll get back to you if we think we could be a good fit.
Submitting information through this portal does not create a lawyer-client relationship.
